Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mark Brody's avatar

Very cogently argued defense of germ theory. Your essay is missing a few things, which I hope you can put in your next essay. First, the scientific evidence showing viral transmission is the cause of viral infection. Second, scientific evidence for purified samples of viruses.

It is my understanding that the "no-virus" people have been mischaracterized in what is in all a likelihood a psy-op which attempts to make them look ridiculous by imputing that they claim viruses don't exist. Having read through this literature, including works by Cowan, Kaufman, Lanza, Samantha Bailey, Mark Bailey, and others, these individuals are merely exposing the gaps in the science supporting the viral contagion theory. Far from claiming that viruses "don't exist" as has often been incorrectly ascribed to them, most of them usually take a more measured perspective, saying that viruses have not been "proven" scientifically to exist. Some admittedly go to far, but most stick to the science. The failure of viruses to satisfy Koch's or Rogers' criteria is dismissed out of hand by the pro-virus crowd. Personally, as you may suspect, I myself take an agnostic view of viruses -- namely that they have neither been proven to exist nor not to exist. I'm in favor of better science offering superior evidence than we now have. I do confess that viral infection makes a great theory, and explains a lot. I do not have a better explanation. Nor do the virus skeptics. However, the ignorance of one side is not proof that the other side is correct. Scientific evidence must be the final arbiter.

Mees Baaijen's avatar

Somebody just posted a two word comment (counted by Joseph Biden) which I can't find anymore: the Rosenau experiment.

Rosenau could not inoculate volunteers with excretions of the patients of the great influenza epidemic of 1918. I will study this more, I remember that other came to the conclusion that something else than a flu virus was involved.

106 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?